View Full Version : Kansas libraries bans cds

08-09-2004, 10:56 AM

'OutKast' not allowed in Kansas libraries

Friday, August 6, 2004 Posted: 7:41 PM EDT (2341 GMT)

KANSAS CITY, Missouri (AP) -- The Kansas attorney general has withheld more than 1,600 compact discs from distribution to state libraries because officials determined the albums promote violence or illegal activity, records show.

The albums removed by Attorney General Phill Kline's office were part of 51,000 discs given to Kansas as part of a nationwide settlement to resolve allegations of price fixing.

The confiscated CDs included recordings by 25 musicians, including rap artists such as OutKast and Notorious B.I.G., rock bands Rage Against the Machine and Stone Temple Pilots, and even older acts such as Lou Reed and the 1980s experimental group Devo.

The list of albums was obtained by The Associated Press last week through an open-records request.

The American Civil Liberties Union said the decision amounted to censorship.

"What he's doing is enforcing his concept of decency on libraries around the state of Kansas, and that's not his business," said Dick Kurtenbach, executive director of the ACLU in Kansas and western Missouri.

Whitney Watson, a spokesman for Kline, said the attorney general would not discuss the screening of the CDs but said the decision to remove some albums was made to ensure state officials were not disseminating objectionable material.

Watson said the office's consumer-protection and antitrust division vetted the list. In some cases, they were familiar enough with the albums to determine if they had questionable content. In others, they looked at Internet databases of lyrics.

"We don't have the manpower to look at every album and every song lyric, but we feel we removed most of the albums that did not mesh with the values of a majority of Kansans," she said.

Kansas is one of 40 states receiving the free CDs for public libraries as part of a 2002 court settlement with the music industry over claims of CD price-fixing.

Attorneys general in several other states also have screened their CDs, often removing controversial artists or albums including explicit lyrics. Indiana Attorney General Steve Carter removed 5,300 discs, or 5 percent of the 107,000 his state was scheduled to receive.

The Kansas Library Association, which advocates for public libraries, said it had no objection to the attorney general's actions.

"This was very similar to what libraries do all the time," said Rosanne Siemens, the group's executive director. "It wasn't so much an issue of taking things out but determining what would be best. They did libraries a big favor by selecting these CDs because there's no way libraries could have said what they wanted."
Violence and illegal activities?
Apparently these people have never read a book.

Exhaust Port
08-09-2004, 11:39 AM
I would venture a guess that the same topics/subjects they object to in the music is found among the books in their library.

08-09-2004, 11:52 AM
When I read the thread title, I thought it meant they banned ALL CDs due to people borrowing them and then copying them illegally. :crazed:

El Chuxter
08-09-2004, 11:58 AM
So in theory I could go into a library and check out Speakerboxx/The Love Below? I wasn't aware of that.

"Hey, ya, heeeeeey ya!"

Exhaust Port
08-09-2004, 12:17 PM
CD's and DVD's are available but copying either would be illegal. ;)

Mr. JabbaJohnL
08-09-2004, 12:53 PM
All my library ever has is a bunch of crap! I wonder if they did this too, or just have bad selections.

08-11-2004, 08:40 PM
Since violence and naughty words are so bad, perhaps they can throw nearly every work of literature, every religious text, and every tome on military history on the fire as well. :rolleyes: Just like the bonfires in Germany, I swear.

I would like to thank these attorneys general for being so diligent in safeguarding our morality. I think if I heard "I Shot the Sheriff", I might actually go out and pop a cap in the sheriff! :rolleyes: