PDA

View Full Version : All in all, what do you think??



hairless chewie
04-26-2002, 05:46 AM
I remember a few months ago the forums were ablaze with different opinions on the AOTC figures.(JJB fighting off several attacks if I remember correctly) Now most of us have our hands on these little buggers and I'm interested if opinions have changed either way. Me, I still don't have even one figure. Such is the curse of being stationed overseas. :( From what I've read it seems like most people are pleased with the whole deal with a few exceptions(mostly collection one figures). Which figure has suprised you? Which one disappointed you?
As a side note, you don't know how hard it is to watch April 23 pass and still not have one single new figure. I feel like scratching my eyeballs out!!! When I finally hit the states in June, god forbid if you are in that Wal-Mart aisle with me!!:crazed:

DARTH_SKELETOR
04-26-2002, 06:31 AM
Man, I really feel bad for you:( Is there anyway you can have them shipped there?? If so, I would not charge any more then wal-mart($5.88+tax+shipping). But I have the feeling your in the ARMY or something, so I dont guess you can get these shipped to you huh? Will if you can, and want to I will help you out.


Me? I am very happy with them!!!!!!!!! I can not believe how great the deluxe figures are alone!!!

hairless chewie
04-26-2002, 08:26 AM
Thanks for the offer of help D.S.! Your offer is what makes this hobby/obsession/addiction so great! I'll be in the states the first week of June so I'll get my fill then. If I was still over here I would have taken you up on your offer. I just lost out on the experiance of APR 23. You can see pictures all day but it's not the same as walking down the aisle and rambling thru the pegs. The satisfaction of it if you know what I mean. You know patience is the WORST virtue!!!! Thanks again!

The deluxe do look pretty good to me, at least they seem Deluxe and not some lame lightsaber swinging action. Which one is the best?

Taichi
04-26-2002, 08:43 AM
Luckily, I managed to avoid most of the figure pics in the days and months before the line was released.....this had two advantages: one, I didn't bother to look, because I knew I'd want some of 'em......and knowing I couldn't have them, would have been agonizing.......it also allowed me to fill in some holes in my POTF2, Episode I, and POTJ lines before this thing kicked off....

SECOND, It didn't spoil anything for me, until the Preview figures came out (of which I bought the clonetrooper, and Jango.....which is better than the other two that came out).....

so, it was advantageous to me.....

all in all, I like the line, with a few exceptions.....lots of Jedi is always cool....but add to that the fact that there's a LOT of new characters (Which is also cool), and you've got a winning combination.......although I'm not too thrilled with some of the action features (I could give or take any of them).....some are really neat, and non-intrusive.......

Kit Fisto's swinging saber is cool.....it doesn't get in the way, and there's no button or anything sticking out of his ***.....so it's cool.....

but Anakin's flywheel, for a feature that doesn't work half the time.....I'm a little miffed about......but it's still a great figure.....

although, I prefer subtle things like the snap on deflection (Which I love) on Luminara Unduli, and Shaak Ti.......

DARTH_SKELETOR
04-26-2002, 03:27 PM
No problem:D

All four deluxe figures are worth getting.

bigbarada
04-26-2002, 04:47 PM
I was in the same situation as you hairless chewie, once in Bosnia were I missed out on the entire theatrical run of the SEs and once again in Korea where I missed out on the last few waves of Ep1 figures and first few waves of POTJ (which weren't a major loss). So I understand the level of frustration. Although in Korea I decided to fill in my collection using Brian's Toys, sure they were more expensive but I was tired of getting left out of the loop. Are you permanently returning to the states in June or just going on leave? Either way I think it is best to wait as the figures should be more plentiful by then.

DARTH_SKELETOR
04-26-2002, 04:55 PM
Yeah I agree, I think figures like Taun we, and Dooku will be easy to find by then. If not, you can always buy them from me even then for store prices.

Bothan187
04-26-2002, 05:27 PM
I will admit... I gave the toys from my first glimps of them a two big thumbs down. And, well, I hate it when I'm wrong.

A few things I am not fond of, but all and all, I think they are 100 times better then the E1 run. They have silly little kid appeal but hey, they are toys. My overall favorite thing about them is the metalic looking lightsabers given to a most of the figures. I also enjoy my Taun We and Luminara Unduli very much...and not just because I managed to find them. Jango with removable helmet is also quiet fun to go <mask on, mask off, mask on...>

c_richards
04-26-2002, 07:03 PM
I was a bit concerned about the new line of figures when I heard about them, but when I saw that Gentle Giant Studios was doing laser scans of the actors. Now I thought these scans were going to be used for the 3&3/4 figures, so I was expecting a lot. Apparently I guess the scans are for a line of busts that are coming out.

Once that confusion was cleared up I looked at a few scans of the prototypes. I have to say I was impressed with most of the figures. I just didn't care for Anikan (Peasant Disguise). What got me upset, was the fact that the lightsaber hilt was molded into the hand, and the blade has to be pulled out. While this was a throw-back to the figures in 1977 where you had to slide the tab out to "ignite" the blade, I would of rather had a lightsaber that was detachable. It would of added to the play value of the figure...in my opinion!

I have to say the idea of having the hilts of most of the Jedi be made of metal, and implanting magnets in the hands of the Jedi to re-create "force" drawing action was a cool move! Overall, the sculpts look great, and the amount of detailing on the figures, vehicles, and accessories keeps getting better and better!

I thought the Lego sets were top notch with the nod for best set at the current time going to Jango Fett's Slave I. I haven't bought the Republic Gunship yet...but I plan on it! Back to the Slave I, I like the fact that it appears to be more in scale with the other vehicles, and is more detailed. I bought Jedi Duel, Tusken Raider Encounter and Bounty Hunter Persuit, and they are great sets as well!

All gripes aside, Saga is in my opinion the best set of STAR WARS figures yet! I finally think Hasbro is getting the idea. We don't want cheesy "chips" that allow the figures to "talk" (half the time they didn't sound right anyways), we , or at least myself, are not interested in a little paper booklet that tells about the character. I would rather pay $6.99 for a nicely sculpted figure, than $6.99 and get a brick and a lot of extra fluff!

Either way, I am still a STAR WARS Fanatic, and don't plan to change anytime soon! :)

Until the next time....
MTFBWY!

Beast
04-26-2002, 07:30 PM
Originally posted by c_richards
I was a bit concerned about the new line of figures when I heard about them, but when I saw that Gentle Giant Studios was doing laser scans of the actors. Now I thought these scans were going to be used for the 3&3/4 figures, so I was expecting a lot. Apparently I guess the scans are for a line of busts that are coming out.change anytime soon! :)
Yeah, there was alot of confusion about that. The fact is you can't scan in a 6 foot tall person and make a small 4" figure of them. You will loose alot of detail reducing them down. What Hasbro did was have Gentle Giant Studios scan the actors and then have them make 3-D busts of the actor's heads and models of their bodies as well. That way the sculpters have a 3 dimension refrence to sculpt from, instead of having to use flat photographs. It has worked pretty well on some of the figures, many are alot more charecter accurate then in previous years.

MTFBWY and HH!!

Jar Jar Binks

Starfig873
04-26-2002, 08:25 PM
Well I'm actually very impressed with many of the figures. But obviously there are small problems here and there, but they can be easily ignored.
I just like how fun these figures are. :)

hessian44
04-26-2002, 08:25 PM
I must say that I have an overall satisfaction with the new figures. The assortment of new "special features" is diverse, rather than the old CommTech chip.

I am somewhat suprised by negative reactions to this line. The new magnet-lightsaber feature is innovative as are the weapon and deflection blasts. Likenesses are carefully crafted, and varied accessories abound. Compare what comes packed into the C3P0, Anakin Outland, Padme or Yoda packages to figs in the old POTF2 and Epi I lines, and the improvements are clear...more product for your dollar.

Everyone has a right to their opinion, and you don't have to like every figure in the Saga line, but c'mon now!...these are some quality toys. I only hope people aren't as unduly critical about the movie as they are these figures.

BTW...my 4-year old loves the figures immensely!

mark2d2
04-26-2002, 08:34 PM
I agree. The pack-ins this time are pretty dang cool. Anakin's computer consol. Threepio's trunk. And that awesome Tuskin Raiders' weapon rack that's supposedly coming with the third Vader Jr. Oh, and the next Padme has a really cool radar type of thing.

Dryanta
04-26-2002, 08:44 PM
hessian44 welcome.Enjoy yourself and I hope to see you here often.I'll be better able to give an entire opinion once I get everything home from Lay-a way.I am pleased with what I have here though.They are better than I thought they would be.Never take anything personal here.When you need to you'll know it.There are a great bunch of people here and we can always use more.

QLD
04-26-2002, 09:07 PM
Personally, I mis the old commtech chips. They were GREAT stands! I'd rather have that than a lot of the accessories, but especially more than force files, or freeze frames.

Jon
04-26-2002, 09:14 PM
I was a bit disappointed with the poses since I am one that is in favor of neutral poses, but with articulation that we can decide how to stand them and pose them. I planned to buy only the ones that I though were cool looking and keep them in the packaging. That was my intent going into midnight madness and as of today I still only have 6 figures, all still in their little boxes. And I am only looking for 3 more: Count Dooku, Royal Guard & Taun We. These are definately kid friendly toys, which is fine, so at least I am saving a good chunk of change this year.

hairless chewie
04-27-2002, 04:19 AM
Ah yes Barada, the curse of being a collector in the military! You can pretty much bet that every two or three years you will be taken out of the collecting loop and have to catch up on everything when you get back. Germany isn't that bad its just that you have to wait longer for everything! I will be coming back to FT Riley in June for at least a couple of years I hope. I should be able to get mostly everything for a few years with no hassle. But the wait is killing me!!:D

BTW, Barada, you said you went to Bosnia and your avavtar says you are from Alamogordo(sp), N.M.. Did you go with the CAV??? If all this is right then I might be your old TC(D-22). Shoot me a PM if this is right or if I'm way off base.

Eternal Padawan
04-27-2002, 11:47 AM
I think for the most part we were expecting the worst out of these figures so anything better than completely suck was a pleasant surprise for us. The magnteic sabers are cool, most of the gimmicks are neat and/or not intrusive. Some of the figures are preposed which is bad, but some are ripe with articulation which is good. So despite the occasional crap (Padme and Outlander Anakin) I think these figures are decent and look forward to the next wave.

Jayspawn
04-27-2002, 11:54 AM
I like them. I was really against them at first, but they look better in person. I think the action features suck. My Anakin (Hanger Duel) doesn't spin his lightsaber around like he should. And although my Nikto Jedi Knight is a statue figure, he's pretty cool becuase he doesn't have a stupid action feature.

All in all, I like them.