• William Shatner: Star Trek vs Star Wars

      William Shatner goes on a rant about how Star Trek is better than Star Wars. Follow the link to watch the video!




      What do you think of Bill's rant? Let us know below!
      Buy the hottest collectibles from: BigBadToyStore.com and BriansToys.com.


      Comments 7 Comments
      1. JediTricks's Avatar
        JediTricks -
        I think Shatner is great, a larger-than-life personality, but he's way off-base on his reasoning here, that it's only about effects with Star Wars, and that's what makes Trek better. And his point about JJ Abrams is just totally disconnected from reality, there doesn't seem to be any growing interest in Trek that I've seen as a lifelong Trekkie, that movie came and went, people liked it and then mainly forgot about it. There is a kernel of truth running through his points though, that Trek's stories are more human, more about humanity, and on that basis I think he's right, that Trek with its infinite potential of who we are now makes it a better storytelling medium. Star Wars has a few great stories under its belt, but they use humanity as a backdrop for storytelling, using classic archetypes as a shortcut to telling a story, rather than telling a story about the people - that's ok, but it's what makes Star Wars a few great movies.
      1. Beast's Avatar
        Beast -
        After watching that.... I wonder if it's William Shatner who needs to "Get A Life".

        And other than taking place in space, I don't get what he means by SW being derivative of ST.

        Plus I'd put Princess Leia over any of the women on Star Trek. She was feminine, but also an arse kicker.

        Outside of a couple scenes in the Star Trek movies, when did Uhura get to really kick some butt?

        Princess Leia grabs the blaster rifle and starts mowing down Stormtroopers along with the guys. Sheesh.
      1. Blue2th's Avatar
        Blue2th -
        Where did light speed originate? Is it derivative of warp speed?I don't think he's got a clue about special effects, he's just grabbing statements out of the air (or somewhere else) and doesn't know the process.The irony of what he says about special effects is that from the first Star Trek movie to the last JJ Abrams one is that ILM, Lucas owned did them. They wouldn't have been as good without them.Maybe right about the human element of Star Trek, but he's trying to compare apples to oranges here, and we get a discombobulated interview. Sure the stud of the universe would like to hook up with Princess Leia, I can understand that though.
      1. Beast's Avatar
        Beast -
        Faster Than Light travel originates long before Star Wars or Star Trek.

        And we've all seen Star Trek V. So of course he doesn't have a clue about Special Effects.
      1. 2-1B's Avatar
        2-1B -
        why is this 80 year old man dressed like a 15 year old boy?
      1. SirSteve's Avatar
        SirSteve -
        2-1B.... his size Small Affliction shirt is the new XXL button-down!
      1. Tycho's Avatar
        Tycho -
        I love both Star Wars and Star Trek.

        They can be apples and oranges next to each other, but the Star Wars prequels added a more complicated story to SW that asked questions about republican governments and political corruption which appealed to me, but not a lot of other SW fans who just like cool tech (AT-AT walkers), unexplained super powers (The Force, without biological details to it like midichlorians), and simple plots, (i.e. blow up the Death Stars.) That bores me after a while and I like material that explores humanity's dark psyche, more politics and history, etc. - with good measures taken to appease my desire for vengeful violence (with reason behind it, and Saving-Private-Ryan-brutality in implementing it).

        So no - I didn't want to post a soundbyte, one-sentence answer. I don't limit the expression of my intellect, or if you find it lacking, I also don't hamper it further developing by posting something simplified. So don't read further, drink something to kill your brain cells instead.

        Meanwhile, Major Kira (Star Trek Deep Space Nine) was a flawed and tragic character better representing any lady character in either franchise (though she's not "hotter" than Slave Leia or Arena Padme in a ripped shirt (and I liked her deleted scene outfit from Naboo), and she's not as "perfect, intellectually" as starship commander Captain Janeway either. Complete Trek fans are familiar with Deep Space Nine and may know what i'm talking about - Major (Colonel) Kira was the best lady character. Perhaps Star Trek's sexiest, was B'llana Torres, the half-Klingon gal from Voyager, if only because I'm attracted to women I constantly fight with - as if nothing else, (well, besides the requisite good looks) they have a personality.
    • Recent Forum Posts

      Tycho

      The Force Awakens products to hit September 4

      Maz Kanata's Castle aliens would be a great exclusive.

      Tycho 5 Hours Ago Go to last post
      Tycho

      What have you watched recently?

      I am binge watching my Hell on Wheels DVDs. I can't stop that show was so good and it is one of the only series with a perfect satisfying conclusion that

      Tycho 5 Hours Ago Go to last post
      Tycho

      Star Wars Rebels - Season 3

      I told you Kallus would turn into a good guy. Thrawn is cold. He's portrayed perfectly like the books!

      Tycho 5 Hours Ago Go to last post
      Tycho

      Happy Birthday Tycho

      Thank you guys! It's nice seeing your messages. I had a good birthday with friends.

      Tycho 5 Hours Ago Go to last post
      Bel-Cam Jos

      SSG Weightlifting/Gym/Exercising Thread

      I often do just that, but this time it wasn't safe (unless I wanted to take a chance with the potential of cars on the other side). I did not move closer,

      Bel-Cam Jos 8 Hours Ago Go to last post
      JimJamBonds

      How did you spend your Saturday?

      Worked, visit to a walk in clinic for this inner ear thing I've been having, food bed, then up for more.

      JimJamBonds 15 Hours Ago Go to last post
      JimJamBonds

      SSG Weightlifting/Gym/Exercising Thread

      As a runner I can say that even if there is enough room I am happy when a car moves over even just a foot because then I know that they see me. In similar

      JimJamBonds 16 Hours Ago Go to last post
      JimJamBonds

      How is the weather by you today?

      27 and windy. Goodbye 'warm' fall.

      JimJamBonds 16 Hours Ago Go to last post
      JimJamBonds

      Happy Birthday Tycho

      Happy birthday Tycho!

      JT, I send the same clip to friends of mine when its their big day!

      JimJamBonds 16 Hours Ago Go to last post
      JimJamBonds

      It's College Football Again!

      Yeah against Wisconsin. To quote Homer Simpson "hey how' bout that.'

      JimJamBonds 16 Hours Ago Go to last post
    Single Sign On provided by vBSSO