Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 16

Thread: Windtalkers

Hybrid View

  1. #1

    Windtalkers

    I saw this today. It's an absolute masterpiece, just like all of John Woo's films (although M:I-2 was boring, the last half-hour was great.) The best WWII film ever made recently, second only to Saving Private Ryan. Very accurate historically, and some of the most loud and satisfyingly powerful battle scenes ever made.

    However, I still think that Face/Off is Woo's best Hollywood film, and The Killer is his best Hong Kong film.

  2. #2
    I liked it, and thought it was good overall. Nic Coppola managed to insert some of his overacting, but for the most part he was pretty cool.

    I absolutely loved Adam Beach, that guy made the movie for me.

    Hmm, I'm not certain as to the degree of historical accuracy, History Channel had an episode of History vs. Hollywood last week but I missed it . . . I'll be sure to catch it on a rerun.
    It looked good, as it included interviews with surviving codetalkers as well as Woo.

  3. #3
    My dad's like the biggest expert on military history there is (he has about as many books as the Jedi Archives ) and he said everything in the movie was plenty accurate: weapons, speech, battles, artillery, etc.

    There were a few errors, though. I discovered these for myself:
    -Enders and Ox used Thompson M1928A1s, which in 1944 had already been replaced by the M1A1 Thompsons, like the one Miller used in Saving Private Ryan.
    -Enders was an even better shot than me! He ran, carrying a man over his shoulder, firing his Thompson one-handed (and that's an eleven-pound gun) and killed like 20 Japs right there. His pistol shooting was phenomenal. He did a little dive (or "shootdodge" as Max Payne would call it) and fired seven shots, killing seven Japs. Wow.
    -There were overall the most precise gunshots i've ever seen. Ever single guy that was fired at was hit and killed.

  4. #4
    But the Jedi Archives don't have books Um, I mean, not in the movie (in the novelization they do ).

    Okay, I see what you mean about historical accuracies in the films, what with the more technical aspects and all. What I was referring to was more of the plot issues, like the idea that most codetalkers weren't assigned bodyguards like in the film. But as I said, I'm not certain about some of these issues, so I would like to learn more.

    Your use of the term "Japs" brings up an interesting point. I'm surprised at how many people I have heard use that slur even to the present. I know it was a common word used in reference to the Imperial Japanese (not to mention other, more distateful words) but I am sickened at how it was also applied by many Americans to their fellow Americans of Japanese descent. I don't doubt that the U.S. government's ever-churning propaganda machine (coupled with long rooted anti-Asian sentiments and resentments on the West Coast and elsewhere) lead partially to that problem.
    It's astonishing to see how so many people were influenced by that . . . nowhere near as much as they were by anti-German sentiments during the same time. No doubt it existed, but given the fact that there were so many Americans of German descent already living as part of white America (and I use the term "white" politically), it was just impossible for such hostilities to stick.
    Curious, I wonder how many German Americans themselves hated Japanese Americans because of the war . . .

  5. #5
    Yes, lately, I have seen many racial slurs used flippantly on this site. I have found it very disturbing that people feel that way, and seem to not care what others feel in regards to those words. Every time I have brought it up, I get nothing but grief.
    "Roger Nasty Butler!"

  6. #6
    Registered Eternal Padawan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2001
    Location
    Outside SSG, banging on the window furiously, yelling "LET ME IN!"
    Posts
    2,368
    I was dissapointed with this one. John Woo (who I usually enjoy) had one premise, the morality of protecting the code, and only twenty minutes of solid story telling in the film. The rest of the film is padded with never ending battle shots. It was a weak film in my opinion and the "tragic" end of the film left me with a "Feh." in my throat. The most dramatic part of the film were the scenes between Slater and Willie. They did more with their moments of screen time than Beach and Cage did through the whole film.

    I agree with your assessment of Adam Beach. He is a charismatic young actor (Young? he's my age... ) and I hope to see more from him.
    Who's a sexy kitty? Who is? Yes, you are. You're a SEXY kitty...

    PHONE BOOK Written by Bendis. Art by Jim Lee. Total copies sold: 15 billion.

    "Comic Collecting. Miss a decade, miss a lot."

  7. #7
    Sorry for saying "Japs."

    But these were some of the best battle scenes I've ever seen...far better than the stupidly short ones in AOTC.

  8. #8
    I watched this on opening night with my dad, who hasn't been to a movie theater in over six years (ID4 and Jurassic Park have been the only movies he has watched in a theater in over 30 years!).

    I liked it, while I usually don't like Nic Cage in anything (he's the master of overblown acting), he wasn't his usual annoying self in this one.

    Excellent story, some of the best battle sequences I've ever seen in a war movie and two excellent actors portraying the code-talkers themselves made this one of the better war movies out there. It's too bad they decided to wait so long to release it after 9/11, now that patriotism is no longer fashionable this movie won't get the box office it deserves.

    My current favorite war movie is still Black Hawk Down, but Windtalkers is easily in my top five along with Saving Private Ryan, Full Metal Jacket and The Longest Day.

    You're right about Cage's markmanship skills, Deadeye. I don't think even the 40/40 people can be that accurate in combat. But anyone is a better markman than me with the M-16, as I usually only qualified Markman with 23-26/40. But give me an M-249 or an M-203 and I can tear some stuff up (I qualified Expert on both of those).
    "To be concerned about being grown up, to admire the grown up because it is grown up, to blush at the suspicion of being childish; these things are the marks of childhood and adolescence… When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up." - C.S. Lewis

  9. #9
    I've qualified sharpshooter with an M4 carbine. Not bad, considering the one I used was a left-handed grip with a right-handed barrel.

  10. #10
    E.P.,

    so to quote homer simpson, windtalkers was a "misdirected woo"? which according to homer is any john woo film.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO