Rather than going back in history like the other rate section I thought having a modern poll would be more appropriate. All of us most likely will have differing opinions on how we judge the figures and I expect a bunch of varied responses. So, to better assist those who may be contemplating purchasing these figures I think it would be a great help to others if we list what we like and dislike about out choices.
Here is what I have bought so far.
Obiwan, Anakin, Mace, Ki Adi Mundi, Jango, and Count Dooku.
Let me point out that normally, I only collect Jedi figures. This hobby is too expensive! However, like in my normal collecting, if I think a figure is very well done I sometimes stray. I have seen all of the Episode II related figures. Here are my reviews from worst to best.
9. Zam: Pumpkin Head. Nuff said.
8. Clone Troopers: Out of proportion, chunky. Just don't look right
7. Anakin: Big head and looks like a kid. No cloak. Nice saber!
6. Mace: Ugh, the face is horrible! Where are the robes???? The lightsaber is really the only reason to buy him if you already own EP1 Mace. However, If you missed out on EP1 Mace buy this one!
5. Obiwan: Could use better face detail, Squinty eyes. No Cloak. Nice saber!
4. Super BD: Nice detail. Great looking figure but poor articulation.
3. Count Dooku: Excellent head sculpt. Best proportion.Uniform restricts posing. Cape snap is chincy. Lightsaber not as good as others.
2. Ultimate Jango: Top notch detail. Great proportions. Realistic face detail. Poor way of attaching uniform armor on legs, and trying to fasten the gun belt leg straps will drive you insane.
1. Ki Adi Mundi: I seem to be the lone person on this one. Ki is 100% awesome! His face is one of the best and he seems in proportion overall. His Jedi uniform is the most accurate and has greater detail than any of the others. Ki is also highly poseable. Again, a GREAT lightsaber.
I know I listed negatives in my figures but of those I own I enjoy. All are out of the box BTW!
If I was only allowed to buy two of these I would get Ki Adi Mundi and Jango.
Let's hear your thoughts.