My vote, I like them both. They both have their own unique qualities to them. The 4" have the versitility with playsets, ships, and diorama posibilities, while the 12" just look freaking cool displayed all together on a shelf. Yeah, there are the rehashes of old figures just changed slightly to appear "new", but heck, if I see another rehash version of Han Solo from classic Wars, I might turn to the darkside. I can't wait until 2006, the Star Wars movies will have come and gone, and hasbro will have to think of new ideas to keep us collectors still buying their products. There are so many things they could make that it boggles the mind. Perhaps someday in a far off distant planet, Hasbro would have made everything that our little collector's hearts could ever imagine. Always remember, it could be worse. Just look how horribly the Batman action figures have been handled. How many freaking Batman variations are there? Holy Bat turds Batman!!!