I'm ripping off Ebert and Roeper

Thumbs up or down?

Catch me if you can

Gangs of new york

Goldmember

MIB II

Signs

My review:

Catch- up ***
Gangs- (haven't seen it yet)
Goldmember- up ***
Mib II down- **1/2 (liked some of it)
Signs up- ****