View Poll Results: What version of the Classic Trilogy would you buy on DVD?

1423. You may not vote on this poll
  • The original releases, as first shown in theaters

    171 12.02%
  • The final refinement of the special editions for DVD in 2006

    239 16.80%
  • Both

    1,007 70.77%
  • Neither: I don't want the DVDs.

    6 0.42%
Page 1 of 6 12345 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 51
  1. #1
    Registered Tycho's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2001
    San Diego, CA
    Blog Entries

    What version of the Classic Trilogy would you buy on DVD?

    Sure, we've hashed this one out before, but I don't think we ever polled everybody on it.

    Here's what we "know."

    The Orginal Trilogy (OT) as first released, can be transfered onto DVD's and put out immediately if George wanted to.

    The Special Editions as released in 1997 could be transfered onto DVD's and put out immediately if George wanted to.

    There is a ton of expanded footage from the Insider's Guide and Behind the Magic CD-Roms, and more that's already prepped to be put on DVD's as bonus material, and it would take less time to re-use that, to add some selling value to 'the first version' of the OT on DVD.

    George wants to go back to the OT in 2006 and do some more work on it.

    Things like the 'bad Jabba CGI-work' are rumored to be fixed, so Jabba will look right, and the scene stays in.

    Things like adding a scene with Jimmy Smits as Bail Organa on Alderaan right before the Death Star shoots, are less credible rumors.

    Things like more exterior shots of the Falcon battling TIE Fighters in the Death Star Escape could be representative of cool added footage that doesn't really change the original film, but improves it.

    Everyone in the whole world except George likes Han shooting Greedo in cold blood. He was threatening Solo's life, or at the very least mugging him, so Greedo got what he deserved, and Han kept the edge on himself a little while longer.

    There are a lot of possibilities here, but let's keep the poll simple.

    What version of the Classic Trilogy would you buy on DVD?
    BAD Pts Need: R5-C7 lf leg (x2), , R4-P44 right leg BAD Pts Offered For Trade: PM me - I have lots of parts now including BG-J38!. New Kyle Katarn is also available.

  2. #2
    Simply put, when it comes to Star Wars, I want it all baby!
    May the force be with you.

  3. #3

    I want BOTH in ONE package!

    Simply put, I want BOTH in ONE package!

    The way I see it, this should be technically easy to do.

    Each scene is recorded as a "chapter", so some chapters would have two versions plus some new SE chapters.

    You then select which version you want, and the DVD player then plays the appropriate chapters and chapter versions.

    Sounds simple, right? Should be, shouldn't it?

    Now, space may be an issue - having these extra chapters, plus multilingual tracks, commentaries, etc.

    If so, Lucas can just go the route of the Lord of the Rings SE - that is split it up on two discs.

    Sure, means you have to get up to change the disc. But on the positive side, think of all the extra stuff they can jam on to a disc that only has to cover half the movie!

    Now I understand Lucas, as a creative artist, wanting to go back and improve on things or do things that he may not have been able to do. Or tweak the story to better tie into the prequels. All this is valid. And personally, I think it's great to see what he would do differently 30 years later.

    That said, why does his original masterpiece have to be lost in the process? Why can't he also please all his fans, instead of inexplicably wanting to seemingly banish his original versions to the dustbins of movie history?

    George, you can have your cake and eat it too! Just put BOTH versions on the same disc(s)! Where's the problem?
    What am I, a Moisture Farmer, an Angry Loner or a Sith Apprentice - I can't keep up!

  4. #4
    I deffo want both. If we could only have one I'd have the original versions, but I would prefer to have both .

    "You were my brother, Anakin. I loved you!" - Obi-Wan Kenobi
    "There's a gentleness about a total Star Wars geek that is sublime."- Rick McCallum
    My DVD Collection

  5. #5

    And how about some respect for the "original" Special Edition?

    Along the same lines of my earlier post, if by using alternate chapters, you can get both the OT and new 2006 SE, then why not the "original" SE as well?

    The way I see it, DVD is a great format for preserving all of Star Wars history. It should be technically feasible that viewers can sit down and choose one of not two but THREE different versions of each movie.

    Why you ask? Well, why not! I mean books will always say what "edition" they are, so people who are interested can track and study the different versions.

    Now I'm not planning to "study" Star Wars (though I'm sure future film students will). But just as a fan, it's interesting and fun.

    Say Lucas wants to redo Jaba as complete up-to-date CGI - say scraping SE ANH and OT ROJ versions. If he puts three film versions on, you will be able to compare Jabba as a work in progress over the years. Say watching OT ROJ, then SE ANH then 2006 SE ANH/ROJ. To me losing that history is a shame.

    And in the end of the day, if the technology can do it, then Lucas
    should do it!
    What am I, a Moisture Farmer, an Angry Loner or a Sith Apprentice - I can't keep up!

  6. #6
    Rogue II's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2002
    Land of 1,000 Elvis Impersonators
    I want both...on wide screen.
    Yo momma. That's right, I said "yo momma".

  7. #7
    I wish for a four-disc boxed set. One disc for each film which offered the alternative between the OT or the SE (with any new gravy) and one disc of bonus materials which included the "legendary" lost scenes, take-outs and all the cool stuff George usually comes up with.

    It should include the "making of" documentaries that have been previously released and maybe, just maybe, the Holiday Special.

    Hard to see, the dark side is.

  8. #8
    The bonus disc is a must. I want to see all of the deleted scenes.
    "It can't rain all the time."

    "Quote the Raven, Nevermore."

  9. #9
    By the way... I never liked the CG Jabba. Not the one on SE/ANH nor the one on TPM. They should make him look (and sound) exactly like the ROTJ Jabba. THE big, bad-___, huttese gangstah! YEAYH!
    Hard to see, the dark side is.

  10. #10
    I voted both, but as a fan of CGI, I would pick the Special editions if I had to choose between the two. One note: I thimk that they need a little more practice on their CGI to get it right. Why was Gollum (in Lord of the Rings) so much beter than any character in any Star Wars film to date?
    the shield generator will be down in moments, you may start your landing


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO