I guess this topic was sort of inevidable. Perhaps this has been brought up befor, but now that the Matrix is "reloaded" fresh in our minds we should discuss it again.
First off, for arguments sake lets just say that Luke is as talented or more so than the Obi Wan and Anakin we've sceen in the PT. I know we don't see great lightsaber dules from Luke in the OT, but we've got to assume that he has the ability to do things as we'll as his father and his teacher.
Alright, here are my vies. I think that Luke would have him if he had his saber. Neo is the greatest hand to hand fighter ever, but luke would combat any ofensive frot from Neo with his saber. For some reason I don't think Neo could stop a saber from cutting through him the way he did that semitar.
Now, there is a posiblity that Neo could use a saber too, if that was the case I think he'd win. Assuming he has training on it, wich we know would just be a quick download away. He's probally faster than Luke and can do more amazing things (fly, dodge bullets, ect). I think it would be a long fight, but Neo would come out on top.
All things being even, I think they would draw more often than not. Would be an amazing fight.
What do you think?