Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 31
  1. #1

    Discuss the SSG 2011 Fans' Choice Poll results here, now!

    Well, the day has come, thanks to everybody's votes, we have created our master list and sent in into Hasbro so it can be mashed together with results from other fan sites. You already know our top 10, but below is the entire list in order.

    Out of 42 voters, the top voted only received exactly 1/3rd of our voters' support, and it went downhill from there very rapidly. It turns out we fans can't agree on ANYTHING!


    Character # of voters Average vote Total votes
    Cliegg Lars 14 7.0714285714 99
    Sim Aloo 13 6.4615384615 84
    Jocasta Nu 8 8.375 67
    Toryn Farr 9 6.3333333333 57
    Nute Gunray (ROTS) 6 8.8333333333 53
    Guri 7 6.2857142857 44
    Tey How 8 4.625 37
    Noghri 5 7 35
    Captain / Admiral Piett 5 6.8 34
    Cane Adiss 5 6.6 33
    Anakin Solo 4 7.75 31
    Mosep Binneed 4 7.25 29
    Uncle Owen 4 7 28
    Nien Nunb Millennium Falcon 4 6.75 27
    Pellaeon 4 6.5 26
    Sgt. Doallyn 6 4.1666666667 25
    Chukha-Trok 4 6 24
    Joruus C'baoth 4 6 24
    Taym Dren-garen 5 4.6 23
    Barada 3 7.6666666667 23
    Kitster 3 7.6666666667 23
    Ben Skywalker 4 5.5 22
    Rogwa Wodrata 5 4.2 21
    Han Solo Carbonite (Resculpt, Electronic?) 3 7 21
    Kazdan Paratus 3 7 21
    Fozec 5 4 20
    Nikto Skiff (unnamed, Kenner's original "Nikto", expected to be named "Lathe" soon) 5 4 20
    Lt. Pello Scrambas 3 6.6666666667 20
    Anakin Spirit (Sebastian Shaw version) 4 4.75 19
    Geezum 3 6.3333333333 19
    Lando Calrissian (ESB, redesign) 3 6.3333333333 19
    Shasa Tiel 3 6.3333333333 19
    Wald 3 6.3333333333 19
    Wedge Snowspeeder 2 9.5 19
    BD-3000 luxury droid 2 9 18
    Captain Rex (clone, not droid) 2 9 18
    Rune Haako (ROTS) 2 9 18
    Zutton (aka blue Snaggletooth) 2 9 18
    Jaxxon 4 4.25 17
    Tzizvvt 4 4 16
    Jess 3 5.3333333333 16
    Reegesk 3 5.3333333333 16
    Mara Jade Skywalker 2 8 16
    Princess Kneesaa 2 8 16
    Yoda Spirit 2 8 16
    Leebo 4 3.75 15
    Carth Onasi 3 5 15
    Darth Sion 2 7.5 15
    Corran Horn (Jedi Master) 3 4.6666666667 14
    T3-M4 3 4.6666666667 14
    Nomi Sunrider 2 7 14
    Ewok formerly known as Lumat 4 3.25 13
    Cad Bane 3 4.3333333333 13
    Jan Ors 3 4.3333333333 13
    Kal Skirata in Mandalorian armor 3 4.3333333333 13
    Teebo 2 6.5 13
    Nelvaanian Warrior 3 4 12
    Zayne Carrick 3 4 12
    Emperor Palpatine (ROTJ, soft goods robe) 2 6 12
    Emperor Roan Fel 2 6 12
    Sarrissa Jeng (aka "hiyaa!" Jedi) 2 6 12
    Ann or Tann Gella 2 5.5 11
    Marasiah Fel 2 5.5 11
    WED-9M1 Bantha Droid 2 5.5 11
    Commander Willard 2 5 10
    Darth Wyrrlok 2 5 10
    Dormé 2 5 10
    Klaatu green/gray outfit w/ crossed bandoliers (never made previously, used to be nameless, after 7-5-11 named "Yotts Oren", the only Klaatu who appears on a skiff) 2 5 10
    Laudica 2 5 10
    Lowbacca 2 5 10
    Rukh 2 5 10
    Anakin Solo (Myrkr Strike Team Leader) 1 10 10
    Darth Krayt resurrected (Legacy: War) 1 10 10
    Jar Jar Binks (Senator - Padme's Apartment Robes) 1 10 10
    Mantellian Savrip (from the Dejarik game) 1 10 10
    Mungo Baobab 1 10 10
    Queen Amidala Naboo Battle (Ascension Gun) 1 10 10
    Republic Trooper (TOR trailer, fought Darth Malgus) 1 10 10
    Utai (2nd version that Hasbro prototyped) 1 10 10
    Banniss Keeg 5 1.8 9
    Velken Tezeri 3 3 9
    Ark "Bumpy" Roose 2 4.5 9
    Leia Bespin Gown 2 4.5 9
    Rycar Ryjerd 2 4.5 9
    Arleil Schous 1 9 9
    Canderous Ordo in Mandalorian Armor (aka Mandalore the Preserver) 1 9 9
    Jar Jar Binks (Senator - Emergency Powers Speech) 1 9 9
    Jerec 1 9 9
    Kintan Strider (from the Dejarik game) 1 9 9
    Mon Calamari Dancer 1 9 9
    Onaconda Farr 1 9 9
    Ree Yees 1 9 9
    Visas Marr 1 9 9
    Wan Sandage 1 9 9
    Bollux and Blue Max 2 4 8
    Darth Plagueis 2 4 8
    Dash Rendar 2 4 8
    Leia Bespin Escape 2 4 8
    Padmé Palpatine’s Office 2 4 8
    R5-X2 2 4 8
    Ahsoka Tano (Season 3 outfit) 1 8 8
    Beru Lars (ROTS) 1 8 8
    Boc Aseca 1 8 8
    Cade Skywalker (without coat) 1 8 8
    Darth Maladi 1 8 8
    Loje Nella 1 8 8
    Palpatine red - Super Articulated 1 8 8
    Sar Labooda 1 8 8
    Tessek (aka Squidhead) 1 8 8
    Thall Joben 1 8 8
    Vedain 1 8 8
    Wiorkettle 1 8 8
    Yoda (ESB) 1 8 8
    Tenel Ka Djo 2 3.5 7
    Tikkes (AOTC) 2 3.5 7
    Admiral Daala 1 7 7
    Aldar Beedo 1 7 7
    Cassus Fett 1 7 7
    Clone Advisor 1 7 7
    Coleman Kcaj 1 7 7
    Davish "Pops" Krail - Gold 5 1 7 7
    Latara 1 7 7
    Probe Droid 1 7 7
    Rute Gunnay 1 7 7
    Sariss 1 7 7
    Treva Horme 1 7 7
    Kaink (more accurate sculpting, including sculpted hood) 2 3 6
    Gilramos Libkath (aka AOTC's not-really Rune Haako) 1 6 6
    King Terak 1 6 6
    Malani 1 6 6
    Maw 1 6 6
    Nik Sant 1 6 6
    Padmé Green Gown 1 6 6
    Swilla Corey 1 6 6
    Tahiri Veila 1 6 6
    Yoxgit 1 6 6
    Cantina Band Member (redesign) 3 1.6666666667 5
    Toonbuck Toora 2 2.5 5
    8t88 1 5 5
    Anakin Spirit (Hayden Christensen version, POTF2 blue style) 1 5 5
    Dulok Scout 1 5 5
    Eeusu Estornii 1 5 5
    Elan Mak 1 5 5
    Jolee Bindo 1 5 5
    Klaatu "in skiff guard outfit" from Kenner vintage line (until July 5th was known as Yotts Oren, now LFL says name is "Klaatu", never actually appears on a skiff but is on sail barge) 1 5 5
    Padmé with hair buns 1 5 5
    Padmé Yellow Picnic Dress 1 5 5
    Tarfful 1 5 5
    Dass Jennir 1 4 4
    Demagol 1 4 4
    Ebe Endocott 1 4 4
    Eirtaé (battle gown) blond handmaiden 1 4 4
    Erdan 1 4 4
    Imperial Security Bureau Officer 1 4 4
    Kea Moll 1 4 4
    Mandalorian Neo Crusader 1 4 4
    Padmé Geonosis Arena 1 4 4
    Sheckil 1 4 4
    Veedaaz Awmetth 1 4 4
    Vestara Khai 1 4 4
    Yun 1 4 4
    Starkiller, clone of Galen Marek pilot outfit 2 1.5 3
    Celeste Morne 1 3 3
    Cordé 1 3 3
    Garouf Lafoe 1 3 3
    IMP-22 (aka Imperial military protocol droid) 1 3 3
    Marn "Gryph" Hierogryph 1 3 3
    Padmé Poncho (aka Lars Garage Dress) 1 3 3
    Queen Apailana 1 3 3
    Quinlan Vos (Jedi Robes) 1 3 3
    Revwien 1 3 3
    Starkiller, clone of Galen Marek (TFU2 cover art costume) 1 3 3
    Tig Fromm 1 3 3
    Tikkes (ROTS) 1 3 3
    Tsavong Lah 1 3 3
    Vizam 1 3 3
    Commander Praji 2 1 2
    Sith Trooper (KOTOR) 2 1 2
    ARC Pilot from Hypori Rescue 1 2 2
    Commander Stone 1 2 2
    Darth Caedus 1 2 2
    Kal'Falnl C'ndros 1 2 2
    Merril 1 2 2
    Morag 1 2 2
    Noa Briqualon 1 2 2
    Padmé Nightgown 1 2 2
    Queen Jamillia 1 2 2
    San Hill 1 2 2
    SD-7 (aka Imperial communications droid) 1 2 2
    Serra Keto 1 2 2
    ARC Trooper Lieutenant of the Muunilinst 10 from Hypori Rescue 1 1 1
    Bomo Greenbark 1 1 1
    Canderous Ordo (KOTOR) 1 1 1
    Cin Drallig 1 1 1
    Edcel Bar Gane 1 1 1
    Jann Tosh 1 1 1
    Melas 1 1 1
    Montross 1 1 1
    Poggle the Lesser 1 1 1
    Pre Vizsla 1 1 1
    Zekk 1 1 1

    Thankfully, our top 10 didn't have any ties. Had there been a tie, I had set it up so the highest number of voters would have won the slot (hence: "fans' choice", not "fan's choice" ).

    As you can see, while Cliegg Lars had more votes and more voters voting for him, it was Nute Gunray (ROTS) who had the most passionate voters, with a significantly higher vote average than any character with more than 2 votes.

    So, what do you think of the fans' voting choices, far out, just right, or somewhere in between? What is there to argue about, Star Wars collecting fans?
    Darth Vader is becoming the Mickey Mouse of Star Wars.

    "In Brooklyn, a castle, is where dwell I"
    The use of a lightsaber does not make one a Jedi, it is the ability to not use it.

  2. #2
    HOORAY FOR CLIEGG! Hopefully he does well on other sites too.

    Overall I think our top 10 has many good choices, several of which were already on the 2009 poll as finalists. There's a pretty good mix of sources - 1 from TPM, 2 from AOTC, 1 from ROTS, 1 from ESB alone, 2 from ROTJ alone, 1 from both ESB and ROTJ, 1 from Shadows of the Empire, and 1 from Heir to the Empire. None from ANH, I suppose that's a little surprising. Thankfully our EU choices weren't obscure nobodies or boring-looking choices. I'm quite happy with the results.
    My Photos and Reviews: SSG Toy Guide
    My Star Wars Fan Film: The Lazy Jedi
    Follow Me: Twitter | Instagram

  3. #3
    I think it's surprising how low Clone Wars shows up here, folks really don't need that realistic version of it the way they used to since that has its own line.
    Darth Vader is becoming the Mickey Mouse of Star Wars.

    "In Brooklyn, a castle, is where dwell I"
    The use of a lightsaber does not make one a Jedi, it is the ability to not use it.

  4. #4
    Not bad! Two of my ten made the cut (Sim Aloo and Piett), yet Jaxxon continues to elude figuredom (shakes fist in anger). I really think we need a Sim Aloo fig, primarily because he's one the last, if not the last, remaining figures from the Vintage Kenner line that hasn't been made. I didn't know at the time of my listing that figures were ranked in importance from first to last. I basically started with SW, worked my way through ROTJ, and then rounded it off with EU. Had I known, I would have put Jaxxon first. Oh well. Either way, it's a nice spread across the movies and EU.

  5. #5
    No Jaxxon?

    To quote the immortal words of Dr. Andre Young, "**** all y'all ***!!"
    Tommy, close your eyes.

  6. #6
    Nice to see two neimoidians made our top 10.

  7. #7
    Here's Rebelscum's Top 10....

    TOP 10
    1) Toryn Farr
    2) Sgt. Doallyn
    3) Vintage Nikto (Vink'to)
    4) Darth Plagueis
    5) Captain/Admiral Piett
    6) Sim Aloo
    7) Teebo & Ewok w/ E-11
    8) Weequay (Sail Barge/Marksman)
    9) Arleil Schous
    10) Death Squad Commander (Vintage)

    http://www.rebelscum.com/story/front...lts_140813.asp

    And here's Yakface's Top 10...

    1. Sim Aloo (Imperial Dignitary)
    2. Saelt-Marae (a.k.a. Yak Face)
    3. Sgt. Doallyn
    4. Mon Mothma (Return of the Jedi)
    5. Nikto Guard (Vintage Deco)
    6. Shasa Tiel (Ishi Tib from Jabba’s Palace)
    7. Bib Fortuna
    8. Admiral Piett
    9. Nien Nunb
    10. Princess Leia (Ewok Celebration Outfit)

    http://yakfaceforums.com/main/2011/0...-poll-winners/

    And Jedi Defender's (TNI's) Top 10....

    1. Nute Gunray ROTS
    2. Jocasta Nu AOTC
    3. Toryn Farr ESB
    4. Sergeant Doallyn ROTJ
    5. Tzizvvt ANH
    6. Saelt-Marae (Yak Face) ROTJ
    7. Nikto (Vintage) ROTJ
    8. Kitster and Wald TPM
    9. Sim Aloo ROTJ
    10. Cleigg Lars AOTC

    http://forums.toynewsi.com/index.php...#entry16731097
    THE SPY. THE SPACEMAN. THE GODDESS. THE ROBOT. THE GORILLA.

    AGENTS OF ATLAS - Returns in Early 2009.

  8. #8
    That last one should be Jedi Insider's.

  9. #9
    Well, Sgt. Doallyn and the vintage Nikto would be definite buys for me, so I must admit that I like the other sites' lists better.

    There are 2 or 3 that I would buy from our top 10 however. Cane Adiss being the one that I'd be most excited about.
    "To be concerned about being grown up, to admire the grown up because it is grown up, to blush at the suspicion of being childish; these things are the marks of childhood and adolescence… When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up." - C.S. Lewis

  10. #10
    Only one of my choices made the top 10 (Sim Aloo), but I'm happy to see Cliegg come out on top, as he's definitely a character I would like to see in plastic, he just doesn't quite make my own top 10. (Tbh, I'm just really happy Jocasta Nu didn't win.) I also like Neimoidians, and whilst I'm not an EU collector, I think the Noghri would make for an interesting figure, which I would probably buy.
    Big thanks to DarkJedi5, TheRealDubya, obi-dad, morpheus282, Tycho and Kidhuman for great deals/trades.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO