I'm w/ jedi master sal, Y-Wing all the way!
Vader's TIE is kind of boring. I've had it boxed up for a few years now b/c it just hasn't captured my imagination.
Now the y-wing is cool! I realize and agree that it's a little out of scale, but I'm so glad to have it. The detail and paint deco are cool, and the droid prop don't bother me.