WHAT IF: What if you had to buy one Star Wars toy...

**JEDIpartner** · 05-16-2002

and your choices were:

1. Electronic Battle Droid Rifle
2. Rampaging Reek
3. 12" Obi-Wan Kenobi

Which would you buy?

**JEDIpartner** · 05-16-2002

The reason I'm asking is because I have to get a gift for someone and these items are on their list. I am SUCH a horrible person to decide on this and I thought I would ask the forumites for their opinions.

**Dave_Cameron** · 05-16-2002

I'd probably go with the Battle Droid Rifle if the person is a kid and loved to "role play". I'd go with the Reek if the person had any intention of also getting the Nexu and the Acklay. 12" Obi-Wan isn't bad, but it's not the best 12" figure they've ever made.

I suppose I'd go with the Reek or the Rifle.

**187-Maul** · 05-16-2002

if it's a kid I would definetly get him the BD rifle
when I was a kid I loved role-playing with guns and stuff

**JEDIpartner** · 05-16-2002

Well... it's a mid-teen boy, the son of a co-worker. He's a pretty nice kid and a collector as well.... that's why I am so confused as to what he'd like. You know... he's at that age...

**jblodgett** · 05-16-2002

I'd take the 12 inch Kenobi... I'm kind of partial to Obiwan.

Bottom line-- if all 3 items are on his "wish list" then you can't go wrong with any of them.

**eliwankenobi** · 05-16-2002

Hmmmmmm... a mid teen boy. I would venture to guess that at that age he wouldn't be running around shooting his playmates with the BD Rifle (but then who am I to talk - I'm 32 and still play with my electronic lightsabers). I'm just trying to think about what's "teen cool" right now.

Let's see, I'm not personally a big fan of the Reek, and I see these being one of the first "clearance" items.

That leaves 12" Obi-Wan. While he's not the greatest sculpt, I think this one holds the most "collectibility", so this one might be the most appealing.

Good luck.